Review: A Death Long Overdue, Eva Gates (2022)

A Death Long Overdue is the seventh book in the Lighthouse Library Mystery Series.  It's a great example of Eva Gate's writing skills, mixing a fascinating mystery with fun characters and a setting so appealing you'll want to pack your bags for the Outer Banks. Stepping back into the Bodie Island Lighthouse Library feels instantly familiar and welcoming. Gates' descriptions are so vivid, you can almost feel the wind and see the historic lighthouse, making the setting feel like a character itself. It's a book lover's dream spot, tucked away in a national treasure.

The story revolves around Lucy Richardson, a smart librarian who approaches solving mysteries in a sensible, down-to-earth way. She's not just observing; she's actively and logically piecing together a cleverly built puzzle. "A Death Long Overdue" is full of unexpected twists that kept me guessing until the very end. Just when I thought I had the killer figured out, Gates cleverly pulled a fast one, leading to a truly satisfying and surprising conclusion.

Beyond the compelling mystery, the book shines because of its lovable characters. Charles, the mischievous library cat, continues to steal scenes with his charm, and the developing relationship between Lucy and Mayor Connor MacNeil adds a sweet touch. Even the quirky characters, like Louise Jane, make the community feel rich and real, providing both humor and occasional frustration in an authentic way.

"A Death Long Overdue" is more than just a mystery; it's an invitation to a world where books, community, and a hint of danger create an irresistible reading experience. If you're a long-time fan of the Lighthouse Library series or new to Eva Gates' work, you'll be charmed, intrigued, and thoroughly entertained. This book is a shining example of why cozy mysteries are so loved, and I highly recommend it.

Carolina Dean 

Office Book Reviewer

12th House Books