Book Review: Murder Under Cover, Kate Carlisle (2011)

If you love a mystery that’s as much about historical craft as it is about a crime scene, Murder Under Cover by Kate Carlisle is a fantastic pick. The story follows Brooklyn Wainwright, a San Francisco book restorer who knows her way around old vellum and gold leaf. Her life gets complicated when her best friend, Robin, drops off a rare, jewel-encrusted copy of the Kama Sutra for appraisal. What starts as a fun, high-end project quickly turns dark when Robin finds her apartment trashed and a dead man in her bed. With Robin pegged as the prime suspect, Brooklyn has to trade her bookbinding tools for some serious detective work to clear her friend’s name.

The stakes feel much higher in this fourth book because the danger hits so close to home. It’s not just about a stolen artifact; it’s about protecting the people Brooklyn loves. Adding to the excitement is the arrival of her boyfriend, Derek Stone, a British security expert who has finally moved to the city. Their chemistry is a major highlight, and having a professional "tough guy" around comes in handy as the killer starts turning their attention toward Brooklyn. The balance between their blossoming romance and the tension of the investigation keeps the pages turning quickly.

What really sets this series apart is the fascinating "behind-the-scenes" look at rare books. Carlisle doesn't just mention the books; she dives into the actual science of "curing" and restoring them, making the trade feel like a tangible, living art form. This specialized knowledge gives the story a layer of sophistication you don't always find in your average amateur sleuth novel. Combined with the misty, atmospheric backdrop of San Francisco, the book creates a world that is easy to get lost in.

Overall, Murder Under Cover is a smart, energetic read that perfectly blends high-stakes suspense with lighthearted charm. While it definitely hits the classic notes of a "cozy" mystery, the unique focus on book restoration and the strong bond between the characters keep the formula feeling fresh and exciting. If you enjoy a story that is atmospheric, a little bit adventurous, and deeply rooted in a love for history, you’ll find this one hard to put down.

Carolina Dean 
Book Lover in Chief 
12th House Books 

Links

• The Bibliophile Mysteries (Book Series in Order) 
• Murder Under Cover, Kate Carlisle Book Four